[fr] Deux ou trois épisodes de podcasts à écouter. Quelques réflexions sur les commentaires de blog (spam ou non?) et la difficulté d'apprendre à bloguer.
Listen to Greetings from Coney Island. I swear you won’t be disappointed. Just don’t make the same mistake I did, and be a bit distracted early on, not realising there are two parallel stories, told by two women with (to me) very similar voices. I actually reached the end of the story before realising I had missed the whole point, so I listened to it all again. It was worth it.
Another episode of Love+Radio reminded me of a Moth story I heard quite a long time ago now. It’s about a volunteer at a suicide prevention hotline. That story made me understand something about suicide (which I am lucky not to know from the inside): it’s not about wanting to die, it’s about wanting the pain to stop. Like many Moth stories, it’s beautifully told and very moving. Well worth the small moment of your life you will spend listening to it.
I know, this blog is turning into a podcast review. But not only. See.
One of the challenges I face as editor-in-chief of Open Ears is approving comments. Not so much because we publish controversial articles that have people biting each other’s heads off in the comments (not at all, actually), but more because
- spambots are getting better and better at sounding human
- some humans are sounding more and more like spambots.
About the latter: people like me have been saying for years that a great way to get your website or blog known is to comment on other blogs. But that’s not quite the whole story. Aligning fluffy or self-promotional comments on other people’s blogs might get your “nofollowed” links out there, but isn’t really going to do what matters, which is encouraging people to actually know you and read your stuff because they’re interested. Clicks and visits only really mean anything if they come from the heart.
So what does work? Well, actually, being a valued member of the communities you are part of. At the time, during the Golden Age of Blogging, leaving meaningful comments on blogs you read and linked to was a way of being that. It’s not about the links, it’s about the place you respectfully take or are given willingly. Add value. Be helpful. Try and make friends. That’s the spirit of “leaving comments”.
Which brings me to an important piece of blogging advice I came up with while trying to teach my latest batch of students the basics of blogging (it was, to put it kindly, a mixed success): blog about stuff that’s in your head. Write about what you know. If you have to google around to factcheck this or that, find a link, or look up a detail, that’s fine. But if you find yourself doing research and reading up to gather the material for your blog post (and the post is not about your research), chances are you’re “doing it wrong”.
Blogging is this weird thing which as at the same time so easy (for “natural bloggers”) but so hard to learn or teach. I think that is because it touches upon “being” more than “doing”. It’s about daring a certain degree of authenticity that we are not encouraged to wear in our school or professional lives. And it’s definitely not how we learn to write. In a way, teaching blogging is a bit like trying to teach people to dare to be themselves in public. This makes you think of Brené Brown and vulnerability, does it not? Exactly. And that is why, I think, blogging is a powerful tool to connect people.
- Twitter Killed My Blog and Comments Killed Our Links [en] (2010)
- The Blog of Unfinished [en] (2013)
- Conversation in Comments vs. Conversation in Twitter [en] (2009)
- New, Shiny, and Hopefully Spam-Free Server [en] (2011)
- BlogCamp: Bruno Giussani — Bondy Blog Story [en] (2007)
- Get Listed in Technorati Blog Search [en] (2006)
- Newsletters in 2016 [en] (2016)
- Lift12 Stories: James Bridle (Ship Adrift Project) [en] (2012)
- FOWA: The Future of Presence (Felix Petersen & Jyri Engeström) [en] (2007)
- Against Threaded Conversations on Blogs [en] (2008)
One thought on “Stories to Listen to, Moderating Blog Comments, Teaching Blogging [en]”
Some people say social networks killed the comments. It’s so easier to just like or retweet. Actually, I’m often as much interested in comments as in the post itself. And I stopped to follow some blog just because they disallowed comments, in order to optimize their SEO…
The discussion on blogs is not as rich as it was before, but it is still one of the things I really appreciate and look for. And one thing that makes, imho, the difference between a website and blog. Though many websites are opened to comments, a discussion seldom happen when it’s not “a blog” (not sure if I’m clear)