Comments on: An Experiment (Seesmic and The Black Swan) http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/ More than just a blog. Mon, 12 May 2008 03:15:35 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.3.2 By: Andrea Vascellari http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-382387 Andrea Vascellari Wed, 30 Jan 2008 11:58:37 +0000 http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-382387 <p>Love your comments...</p> <p>That's what happens to me when I read an interesting book... It takes really long time to finish the book because I have tons of thoughts that pop up in my mind so at the end I spend lots of time writing down new ideas, post drafts etc.</p> <p>Like I told you via Twitter I really love these videos!</p> <p>About, video VS text... I think that video gives a better and more personal idea of what you want to share, but on the other hand text gives more 'order' to your thoughts.</p> <p>I think that one of the main differences is about the 'experience'. Video offers a totally different 'user experience' than text. This is what we should keep in mind. For example when I look at the content of Fresh Lime Soda I want to have a video experience because I think that is much more engaging for me to watch you and Suw instead of reading a never ending chat.</p> <p>According to which type of 'channel' we are using (video/audio or text) we change also the way we share it and browse it, but of course that's part of the experience we choose to have.</p> <p>(about the down sides of multimedia content I link back to what Bruno said...good comment)</p> <p>This is an interesting topic that makes me think about how people consume content and how the online communication is changing.</p> <p>Andrea</p> Love your comments…

That’s what happens to me when I read an interesting book… It takes really long time to finish the book because I have tons of thoughts that pop up in my mind so at the end I spend lots of time writing down new ideas, post drafts etc.

Like I told you via Twitter I really love these videos!

About, video VS text…
I think that video gives a better and more personal idea of what you want to share, but on the other hand text gives more ‘order’ to your thoughts.

I think that one of the main differences is about the ‘experience’. Video offers a totally different ‘user experience’ than text. This is what we should keep in mind.
For example when I look at the content of Fresh Lime Soda I want to have a video experience because I think that is much more engaging for me to watch you and Suw instead of reading a never ending chat.

According to which type of ‘channel’ we are using (video/audio or text) we change also the way we share it and browse it, but of course that’s part of the experience we choose to have.

(about the down sides of multimedia content I link back to what Bruno said…good comment)

This is an interesting topic that makes me think about how people consume content and how the online communication is changing.

Andrea

]]> By: Stephanie http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-366356 Stephanie Mon, 07 Jan 2008 09:54:21 +0000 http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-366356 <p>You're perfectly right, Bruno. My <a href="http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2005/03/23/podcasting-and-beercasting-thoughts/" rel="nofollow">complaint with audio and video</a> (<a href="http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2007/10/17/seesmic-doubts/" rel="nofollow">and Seesmic!</a>) is that it's very easy to produce (in a raw format) but much more difficult to digest or use. I personally really don't think that this is a viable way of sharing stuff <em>instead</em> of writing about it. But I'm interested, still: do I reach different people? Do I touch the people who view the videos differently?</p> <p>Video is clearly very attractive, and I'm trying to figure out what it is exactly that makes people watch it so much, <em>despite</em> all the drawbacks that you mentioned.</p> You’re perfectly right, Bruno. My complaint with audio and video (and Seesmic!) is that it’s very easy to produce (in a raw format) but much more difficult to digest or use. I personally really don’t think that this is a viable way of sharing stuff instead of writing about it. But I’m interested, still: do I reach different people? Do I touch the people who view the videos differently?

Video is clearly very attractive, and I’m trying to figure out what it is exactly that makes people watch it so much, despite all the drawbacks that you mentioned.

]]> By: BrunoG http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-366326 BrunoG Mon, 07 Jan 2008 09:00:03 +0000 http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-366326 <p>Interesting experiment, and definitely a must-read book. But while video-storytelling make it easier for you to "share", it makes it more difficult for the people at the other end to receive and benefit from that sharing: the same comments and quotes put in a blog post are easily scannable, digestible, I can copy/paste them into further blog posts (hence, further sharing). Video kills all that: people have to watch 36 minutes of videos (in 36 minutes you could have typed ALOT of quotes) to know what you say, cannot scan, can't fast-forward (since they have no idea where to fast-forward to), and can't do any further sharing.</p> Interesting experiment, and definitely a must-read book. But while video-storytelling make it easier for you to “share”, it makes it more difficult for the people at the other end to receive and benefit from that sharing: the same comments and quotes put in a blog post are easily scannable, digestible, I can copy/paste them into further blog posts (hence, further sharing). Video kills all that: people have to watch 36 minutes of videos (in 36 minutes you could have typed ALOT of quotes) to know what you say, cannot scan, can’t fast-forward (since they have no idea where to fast-forward to), and can’t do any further sharing.

]]> By: Tim http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-365338 Tim Sun, 06 Jan 2008 04:11:51 +0000 http://climbtothestars.org/archives/2008/01/05/an-experiment-seesmic-and-the-black-swan/#comment-365338 <p>Good videos, Steph: "The Black Swan" sounds like an interesting book! I especially liked your student strike story: it's true to my own experience! :-)</p> Good videos, Steph: “The Black Swan” sounds like an interesting book! I especially liked your student strike story: it’s true to my own experience! :-)

]]>